Minor losses in piping systems refer to energy losses caused by the presence of fittings, expansions, contractions, and other components. These losses can lead to a drop in system pressure and reduced efficiency.
In this article, we will discuss minor losses in detail, the factors influencing them, the types of minor losses, and how to calculate and account for them in engineering projects.
What are Minor Losses
Minor losses refer to the energy losses that occur in piping systems due to the presence of fittings, expansions, contractions, and other components. These losses result from sudden changes in the flow direction, flow area, or flow velocity and can cause a drop in system pressure. Examples of fittings where minor losses occur include bends, tees, elbows, unions, and valves used to control flow.
While individually, each minor loss may seem insignificant, the cumulative effect of multiple minor losses can be substantial, leading to reduced system efficiency and increased pumping costs. Therefore, it is important to account for minor losses when designing and analyzing piping systems.
Elevate Your Engineering With Excel
Advance in Excel with engineering-focused training that equips you with the skills to streamline projects and accelerate your career.
Minor losses differ from major losses, which are caused by friction between the fluid and the pipe walls along the entire length of the pipe. Major losses depend mainly on the pipe’s length, diameter, and flow conditions, whereas minor losses are primarily associated with the specific components or disturbances in the flow path.
To quantify minor losses, engineers use loss coefficients (KL) that represent the ratio of the kinetic energy loss to the fluid’s dynamic pressure. These coefficients depend on the specific geometry and type of fitting and can be obtained from experiments or empirical data. By calculating the pressure drop associated with each minor loss, engineers can determine the total minor losses of a system and optimize its design for efficient operation.
Factors Influencing Minor Losses
Fluid Velocity
The fluid velocity plays an important role in determining minor losses. An increase in fluid velocity can lead to an increased pressure drop through a component, causing energy dissipation. This is because higher velocities lead to higher kinetic energy and increased resistance to flow, resulting in additional energy loss.
In practice, minor losses are often related to the square of the fluid velocity.
Geometry of the Component
Another factor that influences minor losses is the geometry of the system components, such as bends, elbows, valves, and fittings. Each component can contribute differently to the overall minor loss.
For example, a sharp-edged elbow may cause more turbulence in the flow, leading to a higher loss coefficient compared to a smoother, gradual bend. Thus, designing components with optimized geometries can help minimize minor losses and improve the overall efficiency of a system.
Reynolds Number
While the Reynolds number has an impact on minor losses, in most cases, it can be assumed to be independent of the Reynolds number. This approximation is reasonable since the majority of flows in practical applications have large Reynolds numbers, and the loss coefficients tend to be independent of the Reynolds number at these large values. However, when dealing with low Reynolds numbers, it may be necessary to account for the influence of the Reynolds number on minor losses, especially when dealing with fluids with non-Newtonian properties or turbulent to laminar flow transitions.
Types of Minor Losses
Pipe Inlets and Exits
Pipe inlets and exits constitute an important source of minor losses in fluid systems. When fluid enters or exits a pipe, energy loss occurs as a result of fluid particles accelerating or decelerating due to the abrupt change in flow conditions.
In general, the value of the loss coefficient depends on the geometry of the inlet or outlet, such as sharp-edged, rounded, or smooth entrances, as shown in the table below.
Note that all of these loss coefficient data are only rough estimates. Actual values depend on the design and material of the components and may differ from these listed values considerably. If available, actual data from the manufacturer should be used in the final design.
Expansions and Contractions
Local expansions and contractions in pipe sections cause fluid flow disturbances and turbulence, leading to energy losses. The extent of losses depends on the rate of change of the cross-sectional area and the pipe’s geometry.
A sudden expansion or contraction (abrupt change in pipe diameter) would typically result in a higher loss coefficient compared to a gradual change (smooth transition), as shown in the table below.
Bends and Branches
Pipe bends and branches also introduce disruption in fluid flow, causing minor loss due to turbulence and changes in momentum. In this case, the loss coefficient is influenced by factors such as the radius of curvature, angle of bend, or branch, and the relative pipe diameters, as shown in the table below.
Valves
Valves are essential components of any fluid system to regulate or isolate the fluid flow. The loss coefficient for valves depends on the valve type, size, and flow conditions. Common valve types include gate, globe, ball, angle, and check valves, each with its specific loss coefficient, as shown in the table below.
Minor Loss Calculation
Assuming that the loss coefficient of a component is known, the minor head loss due to the component can be calculated using the following equation:
Where:
- hL = minor head loss due to the component [m]
- KL = loss coefficient of the component [unitless]
- V = fluid velocity at the location under consideration [m/s]
- g = acceleration due to gravity [9.81 m/s2]
To calculate the total minor losses in a piping system, it is important to identify all devices and components that contribute to minor losses and determine their loss coefficients. The head loss at each component should be computed and then summed, together with the major losses, in order to obtain the total system head loss. It is essential to consider all of these losses in engineering projects, as ignoring them can lead to inaccurate estimations of flow rates, pressures, and pump requirements.
Example Problem
Problem: A piping system is designed to transport water at a flow rate of 0.01 m3/s. The system includes a gat valve with a diameter of 50 mm. Determine the minor loss across the valve when it is fully opened.
Solution:
First, calculate the velocity (V) by dividing flow rate (Q) with the flow area (A) through the valve:
A fully open gate valve has a loss coefficient of approximately 0.2. The minor loss across the valve can be calculated using the following equation:
The minor loss across the gate valve is 0.264 m.
